Flexera Webinar Sheds Light on Preventing Software Licensing Legal Actions

SAP® UK vs. Diageo Great Britain Highlights Pressing Need for Software Asset Management and Optimization

Itasca, IL - March 9, 2017 ISSUE: The recent SAP UK vs. Diageo Great Britain court decision is yet another software licensing lawsuit between large vendors and their customers. Enterprise software licensing agreements are complex documents. Companies license software products based on many different license metrics - including a quantity of named users or devices, fixed count of processors in a server, etc. In many software licensing models, once enterprises go above the number of licensed users/devices/processors, they are out of compliance. In most cases, the use of unlicensed copies of software by customers is unintentional - due to contract, product-use rights and license model complexity.

One particular area of licensing confusion can occur when there is uncertainty over what qualifies as a "named user."

In SAP UK vs. Diageo Great Britain, the High Court of England and Wales ruled in favor of SAP UK, which sought a claim of over £55 million against the beverage giant Diageo for "indirect users." This has huge implications for large companies that have integrated customer-facing systems with SAP databases . Since 2004, Diageo had licensed mySAP Business Suite based on a number of named users. A few years ago, Diageo then created two new customer-facing applications on the Salesforce platform to access Diageo's mySAP implementation through a SAP Process Integration (SAP PI) interface which was also licensed. The dispute was whether the license fee for SAP PI allowed Diageo’s sales staff and customers to access SAP data through Salesforce applications, or if they needed to have SAP Named User licenses.

The ruling held that user-license fees also apply to Diageo's 5,800 indirect users, exposing them to an additional license fee almost equal to the total amount paid to SAP for all previous software and services. Therefore the court said that Diageo must pay to license all of these users - affirming the SAP indirect license model.

However, if an enterprise's direct access named users also have access to SAP data via indirect applications, only one license is required. And, if the enterprise has users with accounts for multiple indirect applications, only a single SAP-named user license is needed to cover access to all of the systems. So, there are techniques to optimize the cost associated with SAP licensing across direct and indirect usage models.

But how can an enterprise identify users who have accounts on SAP systems and non-SAP systems, or the optimal SAP license type?

SOLUTION: Enterprises can mitigate the financial risk of SAP indirect access by leveraging SAP Software Asset Management & License Optimization technology. FlexNet Manager for SAP Applications helps optimize SAP-named user licenses by detecting idle users, identifying duplicate users and assigning the optimal license type for each user based on an analysis of real usage data - avoiding buying too many high-cost license types when lower cost licenses meet user needs. In addition, enterprises can discover instances of indirect access and optimize license requirements for non-SAP system (indirect) users.

WEBINAR: Enterprises can learn more about managing SAP licenses with the on-demand Pull out All the Stops and Make the Right Decisions for SAP License Management Webinar, presented in conjunction with KPMG, for gaining transparency on SAP indirect access licenses, optimizing named-user licenses and business packages and finding more ways to manage SAP licenses.



Flexera helps executives succeed at what once seemed impossible: getting clarity into, and full control of, their company’s technology “black hole.” From on-premises to the cloud, Flexera helps business leaders turn IT insights into action. With a portfolio of integrated solutions that deliver unparalleled technology insights, spend optimization and agility, Flexera helps enterprises optimize their technology footprint and realize IT’s full potential to accelerate their businesses. For over 30 years, our 1,300+ team members worldwide have been passionate about helping our more than 20,000 customers fuel business success. To learn more, visit flexera.com.


Ashleigh Giliberto
*All third-party trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Unsere Website benutzt Cookies, um Ihre bevorzugten Einstellungen zu speichern und Ihre Navigation zu optimieren. Wenn Sie diese Nachricht schließen oder auf der Website navigieren, stimmen Sie unseren Cookie-Richtlinien zu. OK, verstanden OK, verstanden